CO₂ corrosion, often called sweet corrosion, is driven by carbonic acid and forms an iron carbonate scale whose protection depends on temperature and pH. H₂S corrosion, or sour corrosion, forms iron sulfide films and adds a cracking risk through hydrogen. Because the failure modes differ, inhibitor chemistry, dosing and monitoring differ too.
A trace of H₂S can make a carbon steel line safer from one failure and riskier from another at the same time. That is why “sweet or sour?” is the first question to settle before anyone picks a corrosion inhibitor.
This guide puts the two mechanisms side by side and ends with a decision guide you can use in an inhibitor review.
Why this matters now
- Mature upstream assets tend to carry more produced water over time, and water is what turns dissolved gas into acid at the steel surface.
- An AMPP reference page citing a NACE study puts the annual cost of corrosion in oil and gas production at $1.372 billion, including $589 million for surface pipelines and facilities and $463 million for downhole tubing.
- ISO 15156 now carries the sour service material requirements that older NACE MR0175 documents once held, so material and chemical decisions need to be read together.
- Carbon capture and storage projects are adding CO₂-rich pipelines to the corrosion agenda, which raises the stakes for understanding the sweet mechanism.
What is the core difference between CO₂ vs H₂S corrosion?
The core difference is the product that forms on the steel and what that product does next.
- CO₂ corrosion is the attack on carbon steel by carbonic acid formed when CO₂ dissolves in water. The corrosion product is iron carbonate (FeCO₃).
- H₂S corrosion is the attack on carbon steel by dissolved hydrogen sulfide. The corrosion product is a family of iron sulfides, and hydrogen released at the surface can enter the steel.
- Sweet service means CO₂ with little or no H₂S. Sour service means H₂S above the threshold that triggers ISO 15156 material requirements.
Option A: How does CO₂ (sweet) corrosion attack steel?
CO₂ corrosion attacks steel through carbonic acid, and the rate is controlled mostly by whether a protective iron carbonate scale forms. The NORSOK M-506 standard is a widely used CO₂ corrosion rate model for carbon steel in hydrocarbon production, which shows how central temperature, pH and CO₂ partial pressure are to the problem.
- Driver: CO₂ partial pressure, temperature, pH, flow and water chemistry set the rate.
- Scale behaviour: FeCO₃ becomes more protective as temperature and pH rise, so the worst corrosion often sits at intermediate temperatures, not at the hottest point.
- Failure pattern: general loss at low-protection conditions, and localised attack such as mesa corrosion where patches of scale break down.
- Flow effect: high shear and turbulence strip scale and film, so elbows, chokes and tees corrode first.
- Inhibitor job: build a persistent film that holds under shear and keeps the scale-free steel protected.
Option B: How does H₂S (sour) corrosion attack steel?
H₂S corrosion attacks steel by forming iron sulfide scales, and it adds a hydrogen-driven cracking risk that sweet service does not have. ISO 15156 treats a gas-phase H₂S partial pressure above 0.3 kPa (0.05 psia) as the trigger for sour service material requirements (Project Materials summary of NACE MR0175/ISO 15156, 2026 update).
- Driver: H₂S partial pressure, pH, temperature and chloride set both the corrosion rate and the cracking severity.
- Scale behaviour: iron sulfide films form fast. At low H₂S they can slow CO₂ corrosion, but they are not uniformly protective and can set up localised attack under deposits.
- Failure pattern: pitting under scale, plus hydrogen damage in the steel such as sulfide stress cracking (SSC) and hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC).
- Material link: ISO 15156-2 sets limits for carbon and low-alloy steels, including a maximum hardness of 22 HRC, so the steel choice is already constrained.
- Inhibitor job: reduce the corrosion rate and the hydrogen entering the steel, while the material choice stays qualified under ISO 15156.
What happens when CO₂ and H₂S are both present?
When both gases are present, the system behaves as sweet, sour or a blend of the two depending on the H₂S and CO₂ ratio, pH and temperature. Most producing wells carry both, so a single-mechanism assumption is the exception, not the rule.
- A small amount of H₂S can form an iron sulfide film that lowers the CO₂ corrosion rate. That benefit is conditional and can reverse if the film breaks down.
- At higher H₂S, sulfide films can turn non-protective and allow localised pitting.
- Cracking risk follows the H₂S partial pressure against ISO 15156 limits, not the CO₂ level.
- A change in H₂S, such as reservoir souring, can shift a sweet system into sour service without any change in equipment.
Which inhibitor approach fits each mechanism?
The right approach follows the mechanism, not the product name. Use the 3-P check before you accept an inhibitor recommendation:
- Partial pressures: record CO₂ and H₂S partial pressures at operating conditions, and compare H₂S to the 0.3 kPa sour trigger.
- Phase and pH: confirm where water wets the steel, and what the pH and temperature are there, since films behave differently on wet gas, oil-wet and water-wet surfaces.
- Persistency under flow: test the film under the shear it will actually see at chokes, bends and risers.
A common failure pattern is qualifying an inhibitor in a CO₂-only loop and then dosing it into a line that later sours. The iron sulfide scale changes the surface the film must adsorb on, so the old performance data no longer applies.
Keep two decisions separate. Material qualification follows ISO 15156. Inhibitor selection follows the corrosion mechanism. One does not replace the other.
Decision guide: choose A or choose B?
- Choose a CO₂-focused programme (Option A) if H₂S stays below the sour trigger, scale protectiveness is temperature-limited, and the main risk is flow-driven metal loss at chokes and bends.
- Choose a sour-focused programme (Option B) if H₂S exceeds 0.3 kPa partial pressure, hardness-limited steel is in service, or cracking and pitting under sulfide scale are the concern.
- Choose a combined programme if both gases are present, the ratio is shifting, or the field is souring. Qualify the inhibitor under both gases, at the actual temperature and shear.
- Monitor either way. Corrosion coupons, probes and periodic inspection show whether the choice is holding.
Quick Answers
- Is H₂S corrosion worse than CO₂ corrosion? It is different, not simply worse. H₂S adds cracking risk, while CO₂ corrosion is more often controlled by scale and flow.
- Can one inhibitor handle both CO₂ and H₂S? Some products are designed for both, but performance must be proven under the specific gas ratio, temperature and shear.
- What H₂S level makes a system sour? Under ISO 15156, a gas-phase partial pressure above 0.3 kPa (0.05 psia) is the commonly cited trigger for sour service requirements.
Next step
Before the next inhibitor review, write down the CO₂ and H₂S partial pressures, the temperature range and the highest-shear location on one page. Then ask whether the inhibitor data you hold was generated under those conditions.
Which part of your system has changed most since the inhibitor was first qualified: the gas, the water or the flow?
Key Takeaways
- CO₂ corrosion is controlled mainly by iron carbonate scale, temperature, pH and flow. H₂S corrosion adds iron sulfide behaviour and a hydrogen cracking risk.
- ISO 15156 treats a gas-phase H₂S partial pressure above 0.3 kPa (0.05 psia) as the trigger for sour service material requirements.
- A trace of H₂S can lower the CO₂ corrosion rate, but the benefit is conditional and cracking risk remains.
- Use the 3-P check before accepting an inhibitor: partial pressures, phase and pH, persistency under flow.
- Keep material qualification and inhibitor selection as two separate decisions.
FAQ
What is the difference between sweet and sour corrosion?
Sweet corrosion is caused by CO₂ dissolved in water, which forms carbonic acid and an iron carbonate scale. Sour corrosion is caused by H₂S, which forms iron sulfide films and adds a hydrogen-driven cracking risk. The distinction matters because material limits, inhibitor selection and monitoring all differ between the two.
What H₂S level makes a system sour?
Under NACE MR0175/ISO 15156, sour service requirements generally apply when the gas-phase H₂S partial pressure exceeds 0.3 kPa (0.05 psia). Sour oil and multiphase systems can have separate criteria, so the standard itself should be checked for each system before it is classified.
Can a corrosion inhibitor replace sour-service materials?
No. An inhibitor lowers the corrosion rate, but material qualification is a separate decision governed by ISO 15156 for H₂S-bearing service. Treat the two independently, and confirm how the standard applies to your system with the operator’s materials engineer.
Why can a small amount of H₂S reduce CO₂ corrosion?
A thin iron sulfide film can form quickly on carbon steel and slow the corrosion reaction. The effect depends on H₂S level, temperature and pH, and the film may not be uniform, so localised attack and cracking risk can remain even when the average rate falls.
How do I choose an inhibitor programme for CO₂ or H₂S?
Record CO₂ and H₂S partial pressures, temperature, water chemistry and the highest-shear location, then qualify the inhibitor under those conditions. Where both gases are present or H₂S is changing, qualify under both, and confirm performance with coupons, probes and inspection.